Contact Us

If you still have questions or prefer to get help directly from an agent, please submit a request.
We’ll get back to you as soon as possible.

Please fill out the contact form below and we will reply as soon as possible.

  • Courses
  • Find a Job
  • Home
  • Law, Transactions, & Risk Management
  • Business Transactions, Antitrust, & Securities Law

Clayton Act - Price Discrimination - Explained

When Charging Different Prices to Different Buyers is Illegal

Written by Jason Gordon

Updated at September 26th, 2021

Contact Us

If you still have questions or prefer to get help directly from an agent, please submit a request.
We’ll get back to you as soon as possible.

Please fill out the contact form below and we will reply as soon as possible.

  • Marketing, Advertising, Sales & PR
    Principles of Marketing Sales Advertising Public Relations SEO, Social Media, Direct Marketing
  • Accounting, Taxation, and Reporting
    Managerial & Financial Accounting & Reporting Business Taxation
  • Professionalism & Career Development
  • Law, Transactions, & Risk Management
    Government, Legal System, Administrative Law, & Constitutional Law Legal Disputes - Civil & Criminal Law Agency Law HR, Employment, Labor, & Discrimination Business Entities, Corporate Governance & Ownership Business Transactions, Antitrust, & Securities Law Real Estate, Personal, & Intellectual Property Commercial Law: Contract, Payments, Security Interests, & Bankruptcy Consumer Protection Insurance & Risk Management Immigration Law Environmental Protection Law Inheritance, Estates, and Trusts
  • Business Management & Operations
    Operations, Project, & Supply Chain Management Strategy, Entrepreneurship, & Innovation Business Ethics & Social Responsibility Global Business, International Law & Relations Business Communications & Negotiation Management, Leadership, & Organizational Behavior
  • Economics, Finance, & Analytics
    Economic Analysis & Monetary Policy Research, Quantitative Analysis, & Decision Science Investments, Trading, and Financial Markets Banking, Lending, and Credit Industry Business Finance, Personal Finance, and Valuation Principles
  • Courses
+ More

Table of Contents

What is Price Discrimination?What is Required for a Price Discrimination Action?What are some types of Required Price Discrimination?What are the Defenses to Price Discrimination Actions?Discussion QuestionPractice QuestionAcademic Research

What is Price Discrimination?

Price discrimination under the Clayton Act means charging a different price for a commodity based upon something other than quality, quantity, or cost of selling. The Robinson-Patman Act, an amendment to the Clayton Act 2, addressed the issue of a seller charging purchasers of commodities different prices. This practice can be anticompetitive when the price is below costs and gives one customer a competitive edge in the market that is not related to operational superiority. 

Next Article: Clayton Act - Section 3 Exclusive Dealing Back to: ANTITRUST LAW

What is Required for a Price Discrimination Action?

A claim under the Robinson-Patman Act must meet the following requirements:

  • Commodities - It involves the purchase of commodities.
  • Like Kind & Quality - The commodities must be effectively the same.
  • Injury to Competition - There must be some effect on the market (interstate commerce), in either:
  • Primary line - The reduction of prices for a buyer in a specific region causes an injury to competitors in that market.
  • Secondary Line - Buyers who are customers of a sellers supplier receive a particular discount.

This rule protects smaller buyers who cannot secure the advantages of larger buyers. Ensuring equal prices for resellers of commodities promotes competition. 

What are some types of Required Price Discrimination?

Specifically prohibited conduct includes:

  • Section 2(c) - limits brokerage commissions related to the sale of goods.
  • Section 2(d) - outlaws granting promotional allowances or payments on good bought for resale, unless such allowances are available to all competing customers.
  • Section 2(e) - prohibits giving promotional facilities or services on goods bought for resale, unless they are made available to all competing customers.

The statute also makes predatory pricing illegal outside of the context of Sherman Act 2, which primarily covers pricing below marginal cost for a prolonged period to drive out competition. 

What are the Defenses to Price Discrimination Actions?

The Clayton Act does allow for defenses to or justifications for price discrimination, including:

  • Cost Justification - Price differentials based on differences in the cost of manufacture, sale, or delivery of commodities are permitted.
  • Good-faith Defense - A seller in good faith may meet the equally low price of a competitor.

Either of these defenses are a pro-competitive justification that might outweigh the restraints placed on competition.

Related Topics

  • What is the Clayton Act of 1914 (Clayton Act)?
  • What is price discrimination under the Clayton Act?
  • What are special arrangements prohibited under the Clayton Act?
  • When are tying contracts an illegal restraint under the Clayton Act?
  • When are reciprocal dealing contracts an illegal restraint under the Clayton Act?
  • How does the Clayton Act regulate mergers and acquisition?
  • FTC Act Antitrust Law

Discussion Question

Why do you think the Clayton Act focuses on vertical price discrimination by sellers of commodities? Do you think the limitations expressed above achieve these objectives? Can you think of other methods of regulating price discrepancies between purchasers?

Practice Question

ABC Corp is a seller of industrial cement. ABC prefers to sell in large quantities because of the lower warehousing and shipping costs. ABC particularly likes to deal with 123 Corp, which has its own warehousing and logistics system that ABC Corp may employ when selling 123 cement. As such, ABC provides special deals and incentives to 123 Corp, which has helped 123 Corp dominate the commercial construction market. If ABC's practices are challenged by the FTC, what would a court examine to determine legality?

Academic Research


clayton act price discrimination

Was this article helpful?

Yes
No

Related Articles

  • Forward Triangular Merger - Explained
  • Funding from Equity Investors - Explained
  • Short-Swing Profit Rule - Explained



©2011-2023. The Business Professor, LLC.
  • Privacy

  • Questions

Definition by Author

0
0
Expand