What is the Collateral Source Doctrine?

The collateral source rule is a clause that appears in insurance coverage or used for insurance-related cases. This rule states that when the court awards damages to a plaintiff, the damages cannot be reduced regardless of whether an amount has been paid to cover the damages by other sources. The collateral source rule prohibits the reduction of damages awarded to a plaintiff who has suffered a damage, injury or disability form a third party. According to this rule, the collection of compensation for damages by the plaintiff from other sources does not serve as evidence for the reduction of damages awarded to him by a court.

Back To: INSURANCE & RISK MANAGEMENT

How does the Collateral Source Rule Work? 

The collateral source rule is a legal principle that is used in a personal injury case. This rule disregards any evidence that a plaintiff has been covered by other sources different from the defendant. This rule mandates a plaintiff to receive due compensation from the insurance company (that serves as the source) and not from other parties involved in the case. Hence, if an amount has been paid by another party to the litigation, this cannot be deducted from the damages awarded tithe plaintiff by the court. Other sources as contained in the collateral source rule includes health insurance and workers compensation paid to the plaintiff. The collateral source rule mandates a defendant to pay the damages awarded to a plaintiff for disability, damages or injuries in full, this is without deducting the amount received from other people.

Basis For and Criticism of Collateral Source Rule

The rationale behind the collateral source rule is to allow plaintiffs to recover damages from insurance companies responsible for the damages, regardless of other insurance coverage that the plaintiff has. Hence, with the collateral source rule, a plaintiff can receive coverage from multiples sources and this does not forfeit the damages that will be paid by the insurance company involved. For instance, if a Plaintiff who suffered injury or disability after an accident received coverage from health insurance or workers compensation, this cannot be used as evidence to reduce the damages awarded to the plaintiff by a court. There are some criticism against the collateral source rule, most critics of this rule argue that it aids double recovery for plaintiffs and it is unfair for plaintiffs to receive a double recovery.

Related Topics

• Insurance Law (Intro)
• What is insurance?
• Captive Agent
• Independent Agent
• Captive Insurance Company
• Underwriter 
• Combined Ratio
• Claims Adjuster
• Capital at Risk
• Assigned Risk
• Contingency
• Incurred But Not Reported
• Actuary
• Qualified Actuary
• Cession (Re-Insurance)
• Burning Cost Ratio
• What is an insurance contract?
• Accidental Means
• Anti-stacking Provisions
• What is an insurable interest?
• What are the common categorizations of insurance?
• National Association of Insurance Commissioners
• Insurance Regulatory Information System
• American Academy of Actuaries Definition
• American Association of Insurance Services Definition
• American Council of Life Insurance Definition
• American Insurance Association Definition
• American Risk and Insurance Association Definition
• LLoyd's of London
• Associate in Insurance Services (AIS) Definition
• Associate in Loss Control Management Definition
• Associate in Marine Insurance Management Definition
• Associate in Personal Insurance Definition
• Associate in Reinsurance (ARe) Definition
• Associate in Risk Management Definition
• Associate in Commercial Underwriting Definition
• Associate in Insurance Accounting and Finance Definition
• Associate in Surplus Lines Insurance Definition
• Chartered Insurance Professional Definition
• Chartered Life Underwriter Definition
• Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter Definition
• Vehicle insurancePrivate Passenger Auto Insurance Risk Profile
• Underinsured Motorist Coverage
• Uninsured Motorist Coverage
• Omnibus Clause
• Health insurance
  
• Health Maintenance Organization
• Capitated Contract
• Point of Service Plan
• Children's Health Insurance Program
• Disability Insurance?
• Credit Disability Insurance
• Life Insurance?
• Cash Surrender Value
• Absolute Beneficiary
• Acceleration Life Insurance
• Accelerated Benefit
• Accelerated Option
• Accelerative Endowment
• Charitable Gift Life Insurance
• Incontestability Clause
• Waterfall Concept
• Annuitization
• Assumed Interest Rate
• Clean Sheeting
• Hazard Insurance 
• Homeowners, Renters, and Fire Insurance?
• Participating Community (Flood Insurance)
• Insurance Considerations for Business
• Business Liability Insurance
• Commercial General Liability
• Liability Risk Retention Act
• Excess Insurance and Umbrella Insurance Policy
• Business Interruption Insurance
• Key Person Insurance Definition
• Own-Occupation Policy
• Self-Funded Health Insurance Plan
• Basket Retention Policy
• Commercial Blanket Bond
• Alternative Risk Transfer Market Definition
• Commercial Property Casualty Market Index Survey
• What are the primary obligations of the insurer?
• Earned Premium
• Reservation of Rights Letter
• Subrogation
• Collateral Source Rule
• What are the primary obligations of the insured?
• Insurance Premium
• Cooperation Clause
  
• Coinsurance
• Co-Pay
• Affidavit of Loss
• What is the general structure of an insurance contract?
• Ambiguity Principle
• Accommodation Line
• What are the common disputed provisions in an insurance contract?
• Absolute Exclusion
• All Risks Clause
• What is required for the termination of an insurance contract?
• Risk Management
• Professional Risk Manager
• Associate in Management (AIM)
• Financial Risk Manager
• Forecasting (Business)
• Objective Probability
• Unconditional Probability
• Enterprise Risk Management (ERM)
• Operational Risk
• Business Recovery Risk
• Political Risk
• Asset Protection
• Performance Bond
• Barra Risk Factor Analysis Definition
• Above Ground Risk (Mining Industry)
• Bumbershoot Policy (Maritime)
• Abandonment Clause (Boat or Vessel)
• Bobtail Liability Insurance (Trucking Industry)
• Anti-Indemnity Statute (Construction)